A Promise Is A Promise

A Promise Is A Promise

Nurse Hal Among The Amish (Book 1)

Author Fay Risner


Home Health Nurse Hal Lindstrom is assigned Amish widower John Lapp.  She offers to stay with his children while he is in the hospital.  Fifteen year old Emma takes care of the household.  Her two youngest brothers are handling the dairy operation.  Hal soon realizes that Emma suffers from depression.  Noah is withdrawn, and Daniel is so troubled he sleepwalks outside, looking for his dead mother.  Drawn to this needy family, Hal discovers they have a secret swept under their proverbial Amish rag rug.  The more she tries to help them the deeper she is sucked into the family’s problem.  Finally, Emma makes Hal promise to stop trying to unravel the family’s tragic secret before it’s too late.  Hal agrees.  When her future happiness is at stake, she wishes she hadn’t, but a promise is a promise.

GEMS: Growing up in the Mid-West I loved the style and tone of the story and scenery.  No purple pose or overly nostalgic descriptions, but rather a simple and honest portrayal of daily life.  Each character is original and thoughtfully developed.  I whole-heartedly enjoyed this Amish tale and believed the contrast between the Plain and English, but also how it is possible to live together with understanding, honesty and acceptance.  The story is not overtly religious but rather focuses on the complexities of relationships and because of this drew me into the Lapp family.

FLAWS: This is not truly a flaw because I love how the author wrote the story, but if a reader is looking for more action or twists based on a typical ‘mystery’ experience, you may be slightly disappointed.  The family secret isn’t so surprising, nor is it terribly shocking, but from the point of view of the Amish it is understandably shameful.  I see this as a story about living up to a person’s word and good old-fashion romance and values.

Bitsy’s Rating: 4 Stars


About bitsybling

Welcome to the wonder world of Bitsy Bling. Thank you for taking the journey into the magical world of her book adventures, thoughts and qu
This entry was posted in Literature & Fiction, Young Adult & Teen and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s